Open Search
Open Navigation

 The Mind Doesn’t Matter Anymore

Some of us are old enough to have witnessed the end of the Hull-Spence variety of behaviorism that featured elaborate equations to explain simple maze learning by rats. Then in the 1970s, it seemed that everything in psychology became cognitive, which perhaps it always was. No living  psychologist, however, was around for the really intense debates and research on the composition of the mind in the early 1900s. If such a person is still around, I hope he or she will see this blog.

Edward Bradford Titchener was a leader in this controversy which revolved around the contents of the mind as revealed by introspection. Thomas Leahey reviewed The Philosophical Background and Scientific Legacy of E. B. Titchener’s Psychology: Understanding Introspectionism by Christian Beenfeldt which presents the controversy clearly and in depth. A central question was whether there can be imageless thought. But the research method used, introspection, was not as controversial. To be sure, there were forms of introspection; Leahey reminds us not to confuse Wundt’s methods with those of his student, Titchener.

Well, all of that is water over the dam, if you get the picture. My question here is whether anyone doing research cares anymore about what the mind is. After all, most current research involves introspection: people speaking or completing some form of questionnaire. Even a yes-or-no response is a form of introspection. And do those colorful brain-imaging photos mean we have pictures in our head or just blood flowing?

Read the Review

The Decline and Fall of Introspection

By Thomas Leahey

PsycCRITIQUES, 2014 Vol 59(3)

http://psyccritiquesblog.apa.org/2014/02/the-mind-doesnt-matter-anymore…

You might also like

Back to Blog
Learn More
young woman talking to therapist

7 Psychology Specializations: Which is Right For You?

By examining the link between brain function and human behavior, psychology can positively influence collective outcomes and...

Learn More
woman talking to another woman taking notes on clipboard

Social Worker vs. Psychologist: 6 Key Differences

If you’re contemplating a career in psychology or human services, you might be both thrilled and overwhelmed by the number of...

Learn More
man listening to speaker in group

How Long Does it Take to Get a Psychology PhD?

Obtaining a PhD in psychology comes with a number of benefits, from the freedom to start your private practice to the chance to...

Request Information

  • 1
    Current Select Interests
  • 2
    Provide Information