Open Search
Open Navigation

In their review of Genital Cutting: Protecting Children From Medical, Cultural, and Religious Infringements, Sussie Eshun and Irina Khusid note how long the circumcision debate has gone on, the differences in attitudes about male and female circumcision, and the need to provide parents with balanced education and information on the topic. However, the reviewers note the difficulty that parents have in obtaining clear, evidence-based information on circumcision. In Western industrialized nations there is little debate over female circumcision; it is considered wrong and is referred to as mutilation. The opposite is true for male circumcision. It is generally presented as a beneficial medical procedure and is deeply rooted in cultural and religious tradition. Medical and religious support for male circumcision creates a power imbalance in this culture that prevents debate, just as the strength of male power and cultural tradition limits discussions of female circumcision in those societies that practice it.

Eshun and Khusid suggest that parents receive information and education on male circumcision prior to the birth of a child and that they be informed that this is an elective medical procedure. However, is this recommendation sufficient, given medical and cultural sentiment? Can parents who see this practice as a violation of the child’s human rights who wish to decline it for other reasons comfortably do so? How do uncircumcised males handle the stigma of being uncircumcized?  Does decision science or social psychology have anything to contribute to this ongoing debate?

 

Read the Review

Circumcision: Old-Time Tradition or Medical Necessity? A Critical Review of the Pros and Cons of an Old, Long Debate

      By Sussie Eshun and Irina Khusid
PsycCRITIQUES, 2014 Vol 59(19)

You might also like

Back to Blog
Learn More
adam anderson

Student Career Spotlight: Adam Anderson

Becoming a…Psychologist Adam Anderson PhD in Clinical Psychology Doctoral Student CSPP at Alliant International University Q: What...

Learn More
Debra Kawahara

Alliant Professor Elected as New President of APA

Dr. Debra Kawahara has a vision of a kind, just, equitable, and inclusive world. The American Psychological Association (APA) has...

Learn More
Eve Walker

Alumni Spotlight: Q&A with Eve Walker

Alumni Spotlight: Q&A with Eve Walker California School of Professional Psychology at Alliant International University MA in...

Request Information

  • 1
    Current Select Interests
  • 2
    Provide Information